Introduction
The majority of organochlorine pesticides (OCPs) are categorized as persistent organic pollutants (POPs) [1, 2]. Because most POPs are semi-volatile, their important pathway for transport is through the atmosphere [3, 4]. Soil contacts directly with the atmosphere and acts as a sink of POPs from the atmosphere [5, 6]. The air-soil exchange is regarded as a crucial process for understanding the environmental behaviors of OCPs. Most OCPs have been restricted or banned for decades, and their atmospheric concentrations have decreased gradually. Hence, OCPs stored in the soil may volatilize into the atmosphere, causing secondary pollution [5, 7, 8]. Moreover, OCP released back into the atmosphere by soil may undergo long-range atmospheric transport, affecting the levels and distributions of OCPs on regional/global scales. What are the current levels and air-soil exchange direction of OCPs in traditionally agricultural regions in China after decades of prohibition and restriction? Currently, is soil becoming a secondary source for OCPs instead of a sink in traditionally agricultural regions? It is challenging to comprehend these problems due to the lack of relevant research on the air-soil exchange of OCPs in agricultural regions.
Generally, research on the air-soil exchange was conducted by simultaneously sampling both the soil and the air [5, 6, 9]. Atmospheric samples can be collected using active air samplers (AASs) or passive air samplers (PASs). However, conventional active air samplers are inconvenient for fieldwork since they need pumping devices and electrical sources [10]. Similarly, PASs using artificial materials (XAD resin and polyurethane foam [PUF]) as passive sampling media still need to be deployed and recalled, and these devices are often lost (in our previous studies), especially when they were deployed in urban regions. Some people will destroy the devices out of curiosity [10-12]. Natural PASs, such as tree barks, have lower sampling costs as they do not require deployment and are easier to obtain from the paired bark and soil samples [13-15]. In addition, tree barks can reflect air concentrations over several years, while PUF or XAD-based PASs can only reflect air concentrations over several months [16]. Hence, tree barks may be more suitable for research on air-soil exchange as the soil concentrations also reflect long-term concentrations. Currently, many previous studies have already investigated the methods to extrapolate the volumetric air concentrations using tree bark concentrations [16, 17]. This study intends to use the extrapolated air concentrations from tree barks to estimate the air-soil exchange of OCPs. This work will provide some useful experience for using natural PASs in exploring the environmental behaviors of POPs.
The Huaihe River Basin, located in the transition zone between the southern and northern climates of China, drains an area of 270,000 km2, serving about 190 million residents [18]. The Huaihe River Basin is adjacent to the middle-lower Yangtze Plain (MLYP), which is one of the most populous and economically developed, as well as the most POPs-contaminated regions in China [19-21]. Hostage to the prevailing southeast monsoon, POPs can migrate from the MLYP to the adjacent Huaihe River Basin through a series of geochemical behaviors, i.e., re-volatilization from the soil, atmospheric transportation, and deposition, or the so-called “grasshopper effect” [22]. Our previous study found that OCPs were widely detected in the sediments and soils of the middle reach of the Huaihe River (MRHR), including some OCPs that had never been used in China [23]. However, the atmospheric concentrations and the air-soil exchange of OCPs in this region are still not fully understood. In December 2018, tree barks were collected in the MRHR for OCP analyses. This study aimed to 1. investigate the residual levels, distributions, and sources of OCPs in the barks from the traditionally agricultural region; 2. evaluate the reliability of tree barks as passive air samplers; 3. investigate the air-soil exchange of OCPs.
Material and Methods
Sampling and Sample Treatment
Twenty-nine tree barks were collected along the MRHR (accounting for ~80% of the total watershed area). Willow, as the dominant species in the study area, was selected as the sampling species. Tree bark can accumulate both gaseous and particle-phase POPs simultaneously from the surrounding air. About 200 g of bark were collected from each willow by the river with trunk diameters around 30 cm at a height of 1.5 m in two different directions. Lyophilized tree bark samples were extracted by ASE 350. Prior to extraction, PCB30, PCB65, PCB204, and pentachloronitrobenzene (PCNB) were added as surrogate standards. Extracts were purified using gel permeation chromatography (BIO-Beads S-X3 resin) for lipid removal and further purified using silica/alumina columns. DDTs and HCHs were commonly used pesticides in China. During the 1950s and 1980s, there were roughly 4.46 million tons of HCHs and 0.44 million tons of DDTs into the environment in China [24]. A total of 23 OCPs were targeted in this study (Table 1), including commonly-used pesticides (DDTs and HCHs), rarely-used pesticides (Chlordane and Endosulfan), and never-used pesticides (Heptachlor, Aldrin, Endrin, and Dieldrin). OCPs were analyzed using an Agilent GC-MS (7890N-5977B, equipped with a 60 m × 0.25 mm × 0.25 μm HP-5MS capillary column). Before GC-MS analysis, 2,4,5,6-tetrachloro-m-xylene was added as an internal standard.
Quality Assurance and Quality Control
(QA&QC)
Procedural blanks, sampling blanks, and matrix spike tests were conducted for QA&QC. Spiked recovery rates were 80%-110%, and the standard deviations of all the targets were <10% (n = 5). Surrogate recoveries of PCB30, PCB65, PCB204, and PCNB were 88±10%, 91±10%, 106±11%, and 96±11% in tree barks. Method detection limits (MDLs) of OCPs were 0.02-0.65 ng g-1. No targets were >MDLs in the sampling blanks. Concentrations of OCPs in paired soils have been reported in our previous research [23].
Table 1.
Descriptive analyses of OCPs in the tree barks of the MRHR (ng g-1 dry weight).
Calculation of Contribution Rates for the Technical and Dicofol-Derived DDT
The contribution rates of the two sources (technical and dicofol-derived DDT) to the residual of DDTs in environmental compartments can be calculated based on the o,p’-DDT/p,p’-DDT ratios in technical DDT, dicofol, and environmental samples. In this study, the equation from [25] was used in the calculation:
where x is the contribution rate of technical derived DDT and Rs is the ratio of o,p’-DDT/p,p’-DDT in the samples. 1-x is the contribution rate of dicofol-derived DDT. Samples with both o,p’-DDT and p,p’-DDT < MDL were excluded during the calculation. In samples with only one DDT isomer > MDL, half of the MDL was assigned to the concentration value of the undetected isomer during the calculation. This approximate calculation will not distort the results of source identification.
Calculation of the Fugacity Fractions (ffs)
The fugacity of each compound in soil and air was calculated as follows [26]:
where Cs and Cg are concentrations of OCPs in soil and air (gaseous) respectively, R = 8.314 Pa m3 mol −1 K−1, T is the average air temperature in Kelvin, and Øom is the content of organic matter in the soil. KOA is the octanol–air partition coefficient of the compound.
Fugacity fractions were used to infer the direction of air–soil exchange and can be calculated by dividing fs with the sum of fs and fa:
It’s worth noting that the calculated air concentrations with tree barks are the sum of gas- and particle-phase concentrations. The gaseous concentrations used in the ff calculation were estimated by the proportions of gas-and particle concentrations:
where Cg and Cp are the volume-based gas-phase and particle-phase concentrations of OCPs in the air. B is a constant (1.5 × 10-12 m3 μg-1 for OCPs). KOA is the octanol air partition coefficient.
Results and Discussion
Concentrations of OCPs in the Tree Barks
The age of the willows was evaluated through their wood cores, which were collected by using an increment borer (Haglöf Sweden). The results show that all the willows are at least 20 years old. The age of the willow barks is undoubtedly less than 20 years (often several years); thus, collected barks have a similar exposure time to airborne OCPs and can reflect their atmospheric pollution over a long time scale.
Concentrations of total OCPs (∑OCPs) in the barks ranged from 16.00 to 50.35 ng g-1 (mean = 27.60 ±7.48 ng g-1) (Fig. 1). Total concentrations of different classes of OCPs ranked ∑HCHs (16.96±6.37 ng g-1) >∑Endos (2.84±2.75 ng g-1) > ∑Drins (1.96±1.47 ng g-1), ∑DDTs (1.87±0.50 ng g-1), ∑Chlordanes (1.80±1.00 ng g-1) & ∑Hepts (1.70±0.99 ng g-1)>HCB (0.47±0.14 ng g-1) (Table 1). Generally, HCHs accounted for ~60% of ∑OCPs and were the most dominant OCPs in the tree barks (Fig. 1). Similar patterns were also observed in the soils and sediments of the MRHR (accounting for >60% of ∑OCPs) [23]. The patterns were markedly different from those found in the environmental media of the adjacent MLYP, where DDTs were prevailing [7, 27-29].
Compared with previous studies carried out in China, ∑HCHs (16.96±6.37 ng g-1) in the barks of the MRHR were higher than those detected in tree barks of rural China (5.7±12 ng g-1), the upper Yellow River (median = 10 ng g-1), Yunnan Province (0.10±0.028 ng g-1), and the Tibetan Plateau (2.7±2.0 ng g-1) [16, 30-32]. ∑DDTs in the barks (1.87±0.50 ng g-1) were lower than those detected in rural China (5.6±6.5 ng g-1), upper Yellow River (median = 110 ng g-1), southern Jiangsu Province (6.6±3.5 ng g-1), and even the Tibetan Plateau (11±9.3 ng g-1), but were higher than those detected in Yunan Province (0.3±0.42 ng g-1) [16, 20, 29, 31]. Concentrations of HCB (0.47±0.14 ng g-1) were lower than those detected in the upper Yellow River (median = 9.9 ng g-1), but were comparable with those in Southern Jiangsu Province (0.79±0.34 ng g-1) and Tibetan Plateau (0.32±0.14 ng g-1) [16, 29, 31]. Other OCPs were rarely reported in tree barks in China. This is probably because, compared with DDTs and HCHs, other OCPs were rarely used (e.g., Chlordane and Endosulfan) or never used (Drins and Heptachlor) in China [19, 33]. It’s worth noting that these never or rarely-used OCPs were frequently found in different environmental compartments in China, including the atmosphere and soil, suggesting their wide distribution [7, 19, 33]. Overall, HCHs were the main OCPs in the tree barks from the MRHR, while the concentrations of DDTs, which have been extensively used historically in China, were relatively low, suggesting that HCHs should get greater attention in the study area. In addition, some pesticides that have never been used in China, including ∑Drins and ∑Hepts, have concentrations comparable to DDTs in the studied barks, indicating that the regional/global redistribution of OCPs after decades of prohibition and restriction is noteworthy.
Concentrations of OCPs in the soils of the MRHR have been reported in our previous publication [23]. ∑OCPs in the soils were 1.8-63 ng g-1 (mean = 19±12 ng g-1). Similar to those in the barks, HCHs were the dominant OCPs in soils.
Compositions and Sources of OCPs
HCHs and DDTs
Despite the fact that the usage of technical DDT and HCH has been prohibited for decades in China, there are still some emissions of them recently, such as the usage of lindane (γ-HCH > 99%), dicofol, and DDT-containing antifouling paints [23]. In our previous study, α-HCH and p,p’-DDE were the predominant HCH isomers and DDT-related chemicals in both soils and sediments of the MRHR, respectively [23]. Similar results were also found in the barks (Fig. 2).
Overall, the proportions of HCHs in the barks were very similar to those in the soil samples. β-HCH has the highest KOA among HCH isomers and is the most persistent. Moreover, α- and γ-HCH will be transformed into β-HCH in the environment [34]. Hence, the ratio of α-/β-HCH will decrease gradually after the prohibition of technical HCH. In the barks, the mean of α-/β-HCH was 1.5±0.55 and was significantly lower than that in technical HCH (~5-14). Similar to those found in the soils and sediments of the MRHR, isomer ratios of HCHs in the tree barks suggested a significant influence of weathered technical HCH.
Ratios of DDTs and their degradation products were calculated to assess the contribution of weathered and fresh DDT [27]. The ratios of both (o,p’-DDD+o,p’-DDE)/o,p’-DDT and (p,p’-DDD+p,p’-DDE)/p,p’-DDT were >1 in all the tree barks, indicating a significant influence of decayed DDT. Moreover, the ratio of o,p’-DDT/p,p’-DDT was calculated to interpret the contributions of technical DDT (0.2-0.3) and dicofol-derived DDT (7) [25]. The calculation results showed that technical DDT contributed 66±20% of DDTs in the tree barks, and the contributions observed in the barks were slightly lower than those in the soils (87±22%) and sediment (74±30%) of the MRHR [23]. The higher contributions of dicofol-derived DDT found in the tree barks than those in sediment and soil samples might be ascribed to the heavy usage of dicofol in the adjacent area, such as the Taihu Lake region, and the facility of atmospheric transport of o,p’-DDT to the study area [35]. On the whole, DDT contamination in the MRHR was mainly derived from the historical usage of technical DDT.
Other OCPs
Except for DDTs and HCHs, other OCPs (HCB, Heptachlor, and oxy-chlordane) were also widely detected in the barks (detection frequency >86%). Furthermore, Endosulfan-I and -II, Aldrin, and Isodrin were detected in about 60% of the bark samples.
HCB was found to be a major OCP in the atmosphere of the MLYP, where pentachlorophenol (PCP) had been extensively used for schistosomiasis control [7]. However, HCB only accounted for 1.8% of ∑OCPs in the barks of the MRHR, indicating that PCP was not heavily used in this region.
Anhui Province was a hotspot of chlordane usage [36, 37]. In the tree barks of the MRHR, oxy-chlordane was found to be the major chlordane-related chemical and accounted for 91% of ∑Chlordanes (TC+CC+OC), indicating the main influence of decayed chlordane. Heptachlor has never been used as a pesticide in China; however, it can be released into the environment as an impurity of technical chlordane [37]. Concentrations of ∑Hepts (1.70±0.99 ng g-1) were comparable with those of ∑Chlordanes (1.80±1.00 ng g-1) in this study. Non-degraded heptachlor was the major form, accounting for 59% of ∑Hepts. A similar pattern was also found in the soils of the MRHR [23]. This finding suggests there might be some unknown usage of heptachlor in the study area historically/recently [23].
Fig. 2.
The composition patterns of HCHs and DDTs in the tree barks, soils, and sediments of the MRHR (Notes: Soil and sediment data refer to our previous publication [23].)

The ratio of Endosulfan-I to -II in technical Endosulfan is 7:3 [37]. Owing to the faster degradation of Endosulfan-I than -II, the ratio of Endosulfan-I/-II will decline gradually over time. Generally, the ratio >2.3 indicates fresh input, while <2.3 suggests weathered Endosulfan. The mean value of the ratio was 1.1±0.67 in the tree barks (samples with Endosulfan-I or Endosulfan-II<MDL were excluded), suggesting the main influence of weathered Endosulfan.
Aldrin, Endrin, Isodrin, and Dieldrin had never been used in China before, but, they still could still be detected in some bark samples (Table 1) [37]. The concentrations of ∑Drins in the barks were similar to those of ∑DDTs, but were about an order of magnitude lower than those of ∑HCHs (Table 1). Drins in the barks might be mainly influenced by long-range atmospheric transport from other regions where these chemicals were used historically.
Volumetric Air Concentration Calculation
Considering the low cost and the convenience of tree bark sampling, air monitoring with tree bark is useful for understanding the sources as well as the pollution status of airborne POPs [14]. Quantitative or semi-quantitative estimation of volumetric air concentrations through POPs in barks is important for comparing the tree bark data with data obtained by other sampling methods [17]. A widely used bark/air partitioning model was used to estimate the volumetric air concentrations of OCPs from the tree bark concentrations [15-17]. The equations are as follows:
where KBA is the coefficient of tree bark/air partition (dimensionless). CA and CB are the concentrations of OCPs in air and bark (ng m-3), respectively.
Finally, the calculated KBA ranged from 5.5 to 6.9. It was similar to the results of most previous studies [15-17]. Based on the KBA, the volumetric air concentrations of the frequently detected OCPs were calculated (Table 2). The calculated concentrations of ΣHCHs and ΣDDTs were 10.38±4.13 and 0.16±0.04 ng m-3, respectively.
Calculated volumetric air concentrations of ∑DDTs (0.16±0.04 ng m-3) and Endosulfan-I (0.31±0.31 ng m-3) were comparable with those reported in Southern Anhui (∑DDTs = 0.24±0.16 ng m-3, Endosulfan-I = 0.30±0.15 ng m-3) and most other regions of China [7, 19, 38]. Air concentrations of the never-used OCPs, such as Aldrin and Heptachlor, were rarely reported in China; however, they presented considerable detection frequencies in the tree barks. The calculated volumetric air concentrations of them were about several hundred pg m-3 (Table 2).
Air-Soil Exchange OCPs
The fugacity fractions (ffs) were calculated using the soil and gaseous concentrations of OCPs to illuminate their gaseous air-soil exchange. It’s worth noting that the air concentrations obtained from the bark/air partitioning model are the sum of gaseous and particle-phase concentrations. The gaseous concentrations used in the ffs calculation were estimated by the proportions of gas- and particle concentrations [17]. A value of ff = 0.5 represents that the air-soil exchange of the target substance is in equilibrium, while ff >0.5 and <0.5 mean volatilization and deposition, respectively [7]. In consideration of the prediction error, ff between 0.3 and 0.7 is usually identified as equilibrium [6, 7].
The mean and median ff values of HCB, Heptachlor, α-, β- and δ-HCH were >0.7 or even >0.8 (Fig. 3). Therefore, these chemicals had a strong tendency to volatilize from the soil to the air, and soil was a “secondary source”. This finding was partly attributed to their relatively low KOA (log KOA<8). However, the ff values of γ-HCH were obviously lower than those of other isomers (Fig. 3), while the KOA values of all the HCH isomers were similar. Therefore, the air-soil exchange of a specific chemical was also influenced by the residual amounts in the environment and the use history. As discussed above, HCHs in the study area were significantly influenced by weathered technical HCH, and the usage of lindane (γ-HCH>99%) might be rare (Fig. 2). Hence, the residue of γ-HCH in soil was lower, and air-soil exchange is closer to equilibrium. For HCB and Heptachlor, a strong tendency toward volatilization indicated that there were still considerable residues in the soil. Again, the result suggested there might be historical/recent usage of Heptachlor in the study area.
Except for p,p’-DDD, the median ff values of all the DDT-related chemicals were <0.2 (Fig. 3). The median ff value of p,p’-DDD was <0.4. Thus, all the DDTs presented a strong tendency for net deposition from the air to the soil, and the soil was a “sink” for them. These results suggested there were ceaseless atmospheric sources of these chemicals in the study area and adjacent regions.
Table 2.
Calculated air concentrations of OCPs (ng m-3)
The median ff values of Endosulfan-I and Endosulfan-II were about 0.2-0.3, and the first quartiles were about 0.4-0.6 (Fig. 3). The air-soil exchange of this chemical might be in equilibrium or present a weak trend of deposition. The ff values of Aldrin were generally in the equilibrium range. There might be no continuous atmospheric input from them. For Aldrin, which was never used in China, historical atmospheric transport and subsequent deposition might be the primary source.
To sum up, the results of air-soil exchange indicated that the soil in the MRHR has transformed into a secondary source for several pesticides with relatively low KOA, including HCB, Heptachlor, α-, β- and δ-HCH. Furthermore, this study provides some practical experience for employing tree barks in investigating the air-soil exchange of POPs based on the bark/air partitioning model.
Uncertainty Analysis
The present study revealed the residual levels and possible sources of OCPs in tree barks, calculated the OCPs concentrations in air based on the bark/ air partitioning model, and clarified the current situation of air-soil exchange of OCPs in the studied traditionally agricultural area studied. Tree bark has been proven to be an effective nature passive sampler. The bark/ air partitioning model employed in this study was established by Zhao et al. to calculate the volumetric air concentrations of POPs from tree bark concentrations [17]. This model has been demonstrated to effectively reflect the atmospheric pollution level of POPs, including OCPs, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, polychlorinated biphenyls, and short-chain chlorinated paraffin, etc., at regional and global scales [15, 39, 40]. A recent study used the bark/air partitioning model to calculate theoretical air concentrations and successfully predicted the air-soil exchange of short- and medium-chain chlorinated paraffins in the Yangtze River Delta, China [40]. Although the uncertainty of calculating air-soil exchange using the bark/air partitioning model is inevitable, it is still informative to use this model to predict the air-soil exchange of POPs.
Conclusions
OCPs were widely detected in the willow tree barks collected in the MRHR, China, and HCHs were the dominant OCPs. DDTs and HCHs were significantly influenced by the previous usage of technical DDT and HCH. Heptachlor, Aldrin, Endrin, Isodrin, and Dieldrin, which were never used in China, were also frequently detected in the barks, indicating their unknown usage or atmospheric transportation from other source regions. The aAir-soil exchange of OCPs was evaluated using the fugacity model. The results indicated that soil was a “secondary source” for atmospheric HCB, HCHs, and Heptachlor,; while the soil was a “sink” for DDTs. Other targets might present a weak trend of deposition or be in equilibrium.

