ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Partial Substitution of Synthetic Nitrogen Fertilizer with Pig Manure in Karst Paddy Fields of Guizhou, China: Trade-offs among Yield, Nitrogen Recovery Efficiency, and Greenhouse Gas Intensity
,
 
,
 
,
 
 
 
More details
Hide details
1
School of Management Science and Engineering, Guizhou University of Finance and Economics, Guiyang, China
 
 
Submission date: 2026-06-04
 
 
Final revision date: 2026-08-19
 
 
Acceptance date: 2026-09-24
 
 
Online publication date: 2026-11-16
 
 
Corresponding author
Bimo Ren   

Guizhou University of Finance and Economics, School of Management Science and Engineering, Hua tong Road, 550025, Gui Yang, China
 
 
 
KEYWORDS
TOPICS
ABSTRACT
Soil degradation and greenhouse gas emissions caused by excessive application of synthetic nitrogen fertilizers severely constrain the sustainable development of rice agriculture in karst mountainous regions. To identify an appropriate organic fertilizer substitution ratio that balances food security and environmental benefits, a randomized block experiment was conducted in karst paddy fields of Guizhou, China. Five treatments were established in total: a zero-N control (CK), 100% synthetic nitrogen fertilizer (CF), and three substitution treatments in which 20%, 40%, and 60% of synthetic nitrogen fertilizer was replaced by pig manure (designated OM20, OM40, and OM60, respectively). Soil health indicators, rice yield, nitrogen recovery efficiency (NRE), and CH4 and N2O emission fluxes were systematically measured. The results showed that the OM20 treatment achieved the numerically highest grain yield and the significantly highest aboveground NRE (45.2%), although this yield difference was not statistically significant. Cumulative CH4 emissions increased significantly with increasing substitution ratios, while cumulative N2O emissions decreased significantly. Greenhouse gas intensity (GHGI) assessment showed that the GHGI of OM20 did not differ significantly from that of CF, whereas the GHGI values of OM40 and OM60 were significantly higher by 21.8% and 37.2%, respectively. In summary, under the conditions of this single-season experiment, among the 0%-60% pig manure substitution gradients tested, 20% substitution of synthetic nitrogen fertilizer with pig manure exhibited the optimal overall performance. It could maintain a relatively low greenhouse gas intensity while achieving a high rice yield and nitrogen recovery efficiency. It should be noted that these findings are based on a single growing season of field observation, and the long-term effects of continuous pig manure application require further multi-year verification.
CONFLICT OF INTEREST
The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.
REFERENCES (47)
1.
XING Y.Y., XIE Y., WANG X. Correction: Enhancing soil health through balanced fertilization: a pathway to sustainable agriculture and food security. Frontiers in Microbiology, 16, 1644143, 2025.
 
2.
PARAMESH V., MOHAN KUMAR R., RAJANNA G.A., GOWDA S., NATH A.J., MADIVAL Y., JINGER D., BHAT S., TORASKAR S. Integrated nutrient management for improving crop yields, soil properties, and reducing greenhouse gas emissions. Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems, 7, 1173258, 2023.
 
3.
WIN E.P., WIN K.K., BELLINGRATH-KIMURA S.D., OO A.Z. Correction: Influence of rice varieties, organic manure and water management on greenhouse gas emissions from paddy rice soils. PLOS ONE, 17 (1), e0263554, 2022.
 
4.
YAO L., ZHU J., YANG W., ZHAO D., ZHOU Y., LI S., NIE J., YI L., LIU Z., ZHU B. Green Manuring with Oilseed Rape (Brassica napus L.) Mitigates Methane (CH4) and Nitrous Oxide (N2O) Emissions in a Rice-Ratooning System in Central China. Agriculture, 14 (6), 839, 2024.
 
5.
JAHANGIR M.M.R., AGUILERA E., FERDOUS J., MAHJABIN F., AL ASIF A., HOSSAN M., AHMAD H., BAUER M., SANZ COBEÑA A., MÜLLER C., ZAMAN M. Carbon footprint and greenhouse gas emissions of different rice-based cropping systems using LCA. Scientific Reports, 15 (1), 10214, 2025.
 
6.
NIU J., YU H., JIN G. Estimating the GHGs and the MAC of Agricultural Production Systems in China. Ecosystem Health and Sustainability, 10, 0189, 2024.
 
7.
HAN Z., HOU H., YAO X., QIAN X., TAO Q., ZHOU M. Effects of bio-organic fertilizers substitution on gaseous nitrogen losses in rice fields. Water, 16 (9), 1229, 2024.
 
8.
ZHANG L., WANG J., ZHU C., LI J., YANG Q., FU M., WANG Y. Regulatory Effects of Nitrogen Fertilization on Soil Extracellular Enzyme Activity and Greenhouse Gas Emissions in Paddy Fields with Straw Return. Agriculture, 16 (9), 964, 2026.
 
9.
ZHU X., ROS G.H., XU M., CAI Z., SUN N., DUAN Y., DE VRIES W. Long-term impacts of mineral and organic fertilizer inputs on nitrogen use efficiency for different cropping systems and site conditions in Southern China. European Journal of Agronomy, 146, 126797, 2023.
 
10.
REN K., SUN Y., ZOU H., LI D., LU C., DUAN Y., ZHANG W. Effect of replacing synthetic nitrogen fertilizer with animal manure on grain yield and nitrogen use efficiency in China: a meta-analysis. Frontiers in Plant Science, 14, 1153235, 2023.
 
11.
MA Y., CHENG X., ZHANG Y. The Impact of Humic Acid Fertilizers on Crop Yield and Nitrogen Use Efficiency: A Meta-Analysis. Agronomy, 14 (12), 2763, 2024.
 
12.
WANG F., CUI H., HE F., LIU Q., ZHU Q., WANG W., LIAO H., YAO D., CAO W., LU P. The Green Manure (Astragalus sinicus L.) Improved Rice Yield and Quality and Changed Soil Microbial Communities of Rice in the Karst Mountains Area. Agronomy, 12 (8), 1851, 2022.
 
13.
GAO X., YANG S., HE Y., ZHAO Q., ZHANG T. Short-Term Application of Alfalfa Green Manure Increases Maize Yield and Soil Fertility While Altering Microbial Communities in Karst Yellow Clay Soil. Microorganisms, 13 (7), 1445, 2025.
 
14.
GAO X., HE Y., CHEN Y., WANG M. Leguminous green manure amendments improve maize yield by increasing N and P fertilizer use efficiency in yellow soil of the Yunnan-Guizhou Plateau. Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems, 8, 1369571, 2024.
 
15.
PU J., LI Z., TANG H., ZHOU G., WEI C., DONG W., JIN Z., HE T. Response of soil microbial communities and rice yield to nitrogen reduction with green manure application in karst paddy areas. Frontiers in Microbiology, 14, 1070876, 2023.
 
16.
GUAN X., LI Q., JIANG H., MÜLLER W.E.G. Editorial: Ecological distribution, functional diversity, and the biogeochemical cycle of microorganisms in karst. Frontiers in Microbiology, 14, 1265640, 2023.
 
17.
GUO B., JIN G. Beyond the land quantity: Rethinking the role of land quality in agriculture from the efficiency perspective. Socio-Economic Planning Sciences, 98, 102151, 2025.
 
18.
ZHONG J., LI Z., TANG H., DONG W., WEI C., HE T. The application of varying amount of green manure combined with nitrogen fertilizer altered the soil bacterial community and rice yield in karst paddy areas. BMC Plant Biology, 24, 646, 2024.
 
19.
ZHANG K., WAN X., LI C., XIA X., LOU Y., BAI B., LIANG H., HU H. The effects of the combined application of organic and inorganic fertilizers on the annual balance of nitrogen and phosphorus in farmlands. Scientific Reports, 15, 35657, 2025.
 
20.
YIN Y., GUO S., XU Q., LI J., WANG H., ZHUANG Y., WANG Z., HUA L., LIU H., ZHAI L. Co-benefits for cropland yield, nitrogen emissions, and climate impact through multi-objective optimization agricultural manure solutions. Nature Communications, 16, 6415, 2025.
 
21.
LU Z., ZHOU Y., LI Y., LI C., LU M., SUN X., LUO Z., ZHAO J., FAN M. Effects of partial substitution of chemical fertilizer with organic manure on the activity of enzyme and soil bacterial communities in the mountain red soil. Frontiers in Microbiology, 14, 1234904, 2023.
 
22.
LI Y., DING W., HE P., XU X., ZHOU W. Estimating thresholds of nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium fertilizer rates for rice cropping systems in China. Frontiers in Plant Science, 15, 1470774, 2024.
 
23.
LU H., LIU X., LIU X.H., WANG S.S., REN K., GU C.Y., WANG Z., SUN R.B., LI S. Biochar addition in combination with organic fertilizer substitution could effectively improve soil quality and nutrient utilization of rice. Chinese Journal of Eco-Agriculture, 34 (5), 325, 2026.
 
24.
YUAN D., DANG K., YIN J., LIU H., MA T., LIU J., XIANG X. Effects of different proportions of organic substitution for mineral fertilizers on soil methanogenic and methanotrophic communities in paddy fields. PeerJ, 13, e19000, 2025.
 
25.
SUN Y., WANG X., YANG C., XIN X., ZHENG J., ZONG T., DOU C. Effects of biochar on gaseous carbon and nitrogen emissions in paddy fields: A review. Agronomy, 14 (7), 1461, 2024.
 
26.
LIU J., HE Y., CHEN J., HUANG S., SUN Y. Lime application reduces methane emissions induced by pig manure substitution from a double-cropped rice field. Agriculture, 14 (7), 1063, 2024.
 
27.
LIU Y., XIAO J., LAN X., JI J., HOU H., CHEN L., LV Z. Organic manure with chemical fertilizers improves rice productivity and decreases N₂O emissions by increasing soil nitrogen sequestration. Agronomy, 15 (8), 1783, 2025.
 
28.
WU Z., HUA W., NI K., YANG X., JIANG F. Effects of long-term organic substitution on soil nitrous oxide emissions in a tea (Camellia sinensis L.) plantation in China. Agronomy, 15 (2), 288, 2025.
 
29.
CUCU M.A., ZAMPIERI E. In-depth insights into the complex interplay between microbial diversity, ecological functionality, and soil health in rice agroecosystems. Agronomy, 16 (6), 595, 2026.
 
30.
AMIRAHMADI E., GHORBANI M. Unpacking the trade-offs: A meta-analysis of soil fertility, crop yield, and greenhouse gas emissions across fertilizer types (organic, mineral) and cropping systems. Plants, 14 (19), 3005, 2025.
 
31.
ALI N., JIANG Q., AKHTAR K., LUO R., JIANG M., HE B., WEN R. Biochar and manure co-application improves soil health and rice productivity through microbial modulation. BMC Plant Biology, 25, 914, 2025.
 
32.
NIE M., YUE G., WANG L., ZHANG Y. Short-term organic fertilizer substitution increases sorghum yield by improving soil physicochemical characteristics and regulating microbial community structure. Frontiers in Plant Science, 15, 1492797, 2024.
 
33.
XIE Z., SHAH F., ZHOU C. Combining rice straw biochar with leguminous cover crop as green manure and mineral fertilizer enhances soil microbial biomass and rice yield in south China. Frontiers in Plant Science, 13, 778738, 2022.
 
34.
LIU J., ZHANG M., PAN M., YUAN H., SUN S., SUN Q., HE T., MENG J., LIU Z., CHEN W. Pig manure and biochar reduce nitrogen availability and rice yield compared to mineral fertilization in a three-year field experiment. Agronomy, 15 (9), 2242, 2025.
 
35.
FAROOQ M.S., MAJEED A., GHAZY A.-H., FATIMA H., UZAIR M., AHMED S., MURTAZA M., FIAZ S., KHAN M.R., AL-DOSS A.A., ATTIA K.A. Partial replacement of inorganic fertilizer with organic inputs for enhanced nitrogen use efficiency, grain yield, and decreased nitrogen losses under rice-based systems of midlatitudes. BMC Plant Biology, 24, 919, 2024.
 
36.
SUN Y., ZHANG W., XIU L., GU W., WU D., TANG L., CHEN W. Long-term fertilization regimes modulate dissolved organic matter molecular chemodiversity and greenhouse gas emissions in paddy soil. Biochar, 7, 43, 2025.
 
37.
GUO Y., MA Z., REN B., ZHAO B., LIU P., ZHANG J. Effects of humic acid added to controlled-release fertilizer on summer maize yield, nitrogen use efficiency and greenhouse gas emission. Agriculture, 12 (4), 448, 2022.
 
38.
SUN Z., WANG C., WANG J., WU G., YUAN M., ZOU H., SUN Y. Impact of biological manure substitution on grain yield, nitrogen recovery efficiency, and soil biochemical properties. PeerJ, 12, e17475, 2024.
 
39.
CAI Y., XIAO J., LIAO X., DONG Y., PAN B., ZHANG L., XIE G., CHEN Y., XIE Y. Dryland-to-paddy conversions lead to short-term decreases in soil organic carbon and carbon pool management index in karst soil of Guizhou province, China. Agriculture, 15 (4), 396, 2025.
 
40.
MA S., ZHANG Y., LU J., LU Z., ZHU J., ZHANG W., LI X. Soil organic carbon stabilization by organic amendments through iron gate and enzyme latch mechanisms. Communications Earth & Environment, 7, 647, 2026.
 
41.
MONDOL A.T.M.A.I., CHOWDHURY M.A.H., AHMED S., ALAM M.K. Nitrogen dynamics from conventional organic manures as influenced by different temperature regimes in subtropical conditions. Nitrogen, 5 (3), 746, 2024.
 
42.
TANG H., SHI L., WEN L., CHENG K., SUN M., SUN G., LI W., GUO Y. Effects of different long-term fertilization on rhizosphere soil nitrogen mineralization and microbial community composition under the double-cropping rice field. Archives of Agronomy and Soil Science, 70 (1), 1, 2024.
 
43.
JIA Q., ZHENG H., SHI Z., LIU X., SUN D., ZHANG J. Effects of straw and green manure addition on crop yield, soil properties and CH₄ emissions: A meta-analysis. Agronomy, 14 (11), 2724, 2024.
 
44.
DING Y., WANG M., DU X., HE X., XU T., LIU X., SONG F. The impact of elevated CO2 on methanogen abundance and methane emissions in terrestrial ecosystems: A meta-analysis. iScience, 27 (12), 111504, 2024.
 
45.
WANG Z., LI Y., LIU X., JU X. Integrated manure application enhances soil quality and reduces nitrous oxide emissions by deterministically shaping N cycling guilds. Nitrogen Cycling, 1, e007, 2025.
 
46.
XU H., MUSTAFA A., SAEED Q., JIANG G., SUN N., LIU K., KUCERIK J., YANG X., XU M. Combined application of chemical and organic fertilizers enhances soil organic carbon sequestration and crop productivity by improving carbon stability and management index in a rice–rice cropping system. Chemical and Biological Technologies in Agriculture, 12, 1, 2025.
 
47.
LI Z., ZHANG S., SHAH F., XIONG L., WU W. Integrated assessment of yield, nitrogen use efficiency, and environmental impact of biochar and organic fertilizer in cherry tomato production. Agronomy, 15 (7), 1623, 2025.
 
eISSN:2083-5906
ISSN:1230-1485
Journals System - logo
Scroll to top