ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Optimizing the DRASTIC Method for Nitrate Pollution in Groundwater Vulnerability Assessments: a Case Study in China
Haiyang He1, 2, 3, Xuguang Li3, Xiao Li3, Jian Cui3, Wenjing Zhang1, 2, Wei Xu4
 
More details
Hide details
 
1Key Laboratory of Groundwater Resources and Environment, Ministry of Education,
Jilin University, Changchun 130021, China
2College of Environment and Resources, Jilin University, Changchun 130021, China
3Shenyang Center China Geological Survey Bureau, Shenyang 110034, China
4College of Water Conservancy, Shenyang Agricultural University, Shenyang 110866, China
 
 
Submission date: 2017-05-06
 
 
Final revision date: 2017-06-09
 
 
Acceptance date: 2017-06-21
 
 
Online publication date: 2017-11-17
 
 
Publication date: 2018-01-02
 
 
Pol. J. Environ. Stud. 2018;27(1):95-107
 
KEYWORDS
TOPICS
ABSTRACT
Groundwater vulnerability assessments, using DRASTIC, are important and useful tools for groundwater pollution prevention and control. The DRASTIC method, however, is not appropriate for accurate specific vulnerability assessments where nitrate concentrations are high. A new method has been developed that retains the basic structure of DRASTIC while adding or subtracting parameters, and modifying the parameter ratings and weightings. The resulting DRACILM model was used to assess vulnerability to nitrate pollution in the West Liaohe Plain and as a basis for vulnerability mapping. The accuracy, appropriateness, and reliability of the vulnerability mapping were analyzed using a group of integrated indicators, such as correlation, ANOVA F-statistics, and single-parameter sensitivity analysis. The correlation between vulnerability class and the concentration of NO3-N in the DRACILM model improved to 0.649, which was 40.6% higher than that obtained by DRASTIC. The ANOVA F-statistic was 27.71, which indicated a lower overlap between the mean values of nitrates in the different vulnerability classes. The single-parameter sensitivity analysis revealed that land use type exhibited the highest and hydraulic conductivity the lowest effective weighting values. The vulnerability maps by DRACILM model could assist planners and government decision-makers with preliminary investigations into planning water protection projects or establishing management scenarios for water resource quality.
CONFLICT OF INTEREST
The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.
 
CITATIONS (22):
1.
Current status and future challenges of groundwater vulnerability assessment: A bibliometric analysis
Hanxiang Xiong, Yuzhou Wang, Xu Guo, Jiaxin Han, Chuanming Ma, Xinyu Zhang
Journal of Hydrology
 
2.
Water Availability and Management in Mexico
Ana Elizabeth Marín-Celestino, María de los Ángeles Alonso-Lavernia, María de la Luz Hernández-Flores, Ingrid Árcega-Santillán, Claudia Romo-Gómez, Elena María Otazo-Sánchez
 
3.
Nitrate vulnerability of groundwater in Jeju Volcanic Island, Korea
Eunhye Kwon, Jonghoon Park, Won-Bae Park, Bong-Rae Kang, Beom-Seok Hyeon, Nam C. Woo
Science of The Total Environment
 
4.
Comparison of DRASTIC and DRASTICL groundwater vulnerability assessments of the Burdekin Basin, Queensland, Australia
Nasrin Taghavi, Robert K. Niven, Matthias Kramer, David J. Paull
Science of The Total Environment
 
5.
Implementation and evaluation of different techniques to modify DRASTIC method for groundwater vulnerability assessment: a case study from Bouficha aquifer, Tunisia
Ilias Siarkos, Madiha Arfaoui, Ourania Tzoraki, Mounira Zammouri, Fadoua Hamzaoui-Azaza
Environmental Science and Pollution Research
 
6.
Quantitative Assessment and Validation of Groundwater Pollution Risk in Southwest Karst Area
Mei Liu, Huan Huan, Haixiang Li, Weijiang Liu, Juan Li, Xiaobing Zhao, Aixia Zhou, Xianjun Xie
Exposure and Health
 
7.
Occurrence and distribution of atrazine in groundwater from agricultural areas in China
Shengpin Li, Fuyang Huang, Haitao Piao, Wenpeng Li, Fei Liu, Qianying Zhu, Yaping He, Jialin Wang, Maohua Yan
Science of The Total Environment
 
8.
Local Scale Groundwater Vulnerability Assessment with an Improved DRASTIC Model
Santanu Mallik, Tridip Bhowmik, Umesh Mishra, Niladri Paul
Natural Resources Research
 
9.
Optimized ensemble techniques for nitrate concentration modelling from groundwater integrated with mRMR extraction algorithm
Abdullahi G. Usman, Hisham M. Almongy, Ismail A. Mahmoud, Abdulhayat M. Jibrin, Jamilu Usman, Mohd Saiful Samsudin, Sani I. Abba, Ehab M. Almetwally
Journal of Radiation Research and Applied Sciences
 
10.
Quantifying the Parameters Impact in Groundwater Vulnerability Assessment for Agricultural Pollution, a Review
Efthymia Zavridou, Gianluigi Busico, Erin Leigh Plato, Yassine Ez-Zaouy, Beata Jaworska-Szulc, Adam Szymkiewicz, Nebojsa Jovanovic, Vincent Marc, Ricardo Hirata, Micòl Mastrocicco, Konstantinos Chalikakis
Environmental Processes
 
11.
Assessment of urban groundwater vulnerability in arid areas: Case of Sidi Bouzid aquifer (central Tunisia)
Gammoudi Safa, Chkir Najiba, Boughattas Nour El Houda, Hamdi Monji, Arraouadi Soumaya, Zouari Kamel
Journal of African Earth Sciences
 
12.
Groundwater vulnerability assessment of nitrate pollution in the Ankang Basin: using an optimized DRASTIC-LY method
Tian Hui, Xiao Changlai, Xu Honggen, Liang Xiujuan, Qian Jianli, Qiao Longtan, Zhang Weilong, Zhang Hong
Journal of Water and Health
 
13.
Vulnerability of groundwater to pollution at the Dabiss bauxite mining area, Boké Prefecture, Republic of Guinea
Alpha Mamoudou Diallo, Ahmed Amara Konaté, Fassidy Oularé, Muhammad Zaheer
Geology, Ecology, and Landscapes
 
14.
Study on assessment of groundwater contamination in Shuangliao city based on synthetical factor standard index method
Haiyang He, Wei Dai, Yan Wang, Wenyan Xu, Huan Wang, Xilong Qu
Second International Conference on Sustainable Technology and Management (ICSTM 2023)
 
15.
Nitrate concentration analysis and prediction in a shallow aquifer in central-eastern Tunisia using artificial neural network and time series modelling
Asma El Amri, Soumaia M’nassri, Nessrine Nasri, Hanen Nsir, Rajouene Majdoub
Environmental Science and Pollution Research
 
16.
Influence of Agricultural Irrigation Activity on the Potential Risk of Groundwater Pollution: A Study with Drastic Method in a Semi-Arid Agricultural Region of China
Lingjun Meng, Qixing Zhang, Pai Liu, Haiyang He, Wei Xu
Sustainability
 
17.
A nationwide study on the occurrence, driving factors and exposure assessment of typical pesticides in groundwater in China
Shengpin Li, Jiaqing Liu, Fei Liu, Wenpeng Li, Kun Liu, Haitao Piao, Rui An, Yiwei Zhang, Tuoya Tai, Qianying Zhu, Fuyang Huang
Journal of Contaminant Hydrology
 
18.
Vulnerability assessment, transport modeling and simulation of nitrate in groundwater using SI method and modflow-MT3DMS software: case of Sminja aquifer, Tunisia
Meriem Ameur, Soumaya Aouiti, Fadoua Hamzaoui-Azaza, Lilia Ben Cheikha, Moncef Gueddari
Environmental Earth Sciences
 
19.
Comparison of groundwater pollution vulnerability assessments via the DRASTIC-LU and DRASTIC-LU-NO3− methods in the Ouled Ogbane aquifer, Northwest Morocco
Morad Chahid, Ismail Hilal, Chaimaa Et-Takaouy, Khalid En-Nagre, Jamal Eddine Stitou El Messari, Mohammed Reda Aoulad Mansour, Mourad Aqnouy
Environmental Science and Pollution Research
 
20.
A GIS-based modified DRASTIC approach for geospatial modeling of groundwater vulnerability and pollution risk mapping in Korba district, Central India
Soumya S. Singha, Srinivas Pasupuleti, Sudhakar Singha, Rambabu Singh, A. S. Venkatesh
Environmental Earth Sciences
 
21.
Groundwater Quality and Potential Human Health Risk Assessment for Drinking and Irrigation Purposes: A Case Study in the Semiarid Region of North China
Feifei Chen, Leihua Yao, Gang Mei, Yinsheng Shang, Fansheng Xiong, Zhenbin Ding
Water
 
22.
A Data-Driven Method for Determining DRASTIC Weights to Assess Groundwater Vulnerability to Nitrate: Application in the Lake Baiyangdian Watershed, North China Plain
Xianglong Hou, Liqin Peng, Yuan Zhang, Yan Zhang, Yunxia Wang, Wenzhao Feng, Hui Yang
Applied Sciences
 
eISSN:2083-5906
ISSN:1230-1485
Journals System - logo
Scroll to top