ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Remediation of Pb-Contaminated Soil with Hydroxyapatite and Potassium Chloride: Performance and Optimization
,
 
Xu Xia 1,2
,
 
Xu Han 3
,
 
,
 
,
 
,
 
,
 
,
 
,
 
 
 
 
More details
Hide details
1
School of Environment and Spatial Informatics, China University of Mining and Technology, Xuzhou 221116, China
 
2
XCMG Xuzhou Truck-mounted Crane Co., Ltd., Xuzhou 221000, China
 
3
School of Chinese Language and Literature, Yancheng Teachers University, Yancheng 224002, China
 
4
Tianjin Huankelijia Environmental Remediation Technology Co., Ltd., Tianjin 300191, China
 
5
State Key Laboratory of Coal Mine Disaster Prevention and Control, China University of Mining and Technology, Xuzhou 221116, China
 
6
China Academy of Safety Science and Technology, Beijing 100012, China
 
 
Submission date: 2025-12-26
 
 
Final revision date: 2026-02-15
 
 
Acceptance date: 2026-04-10
 
 
Online publication date: 2026-09-23
 
 
Corresponding author
Ping Luo   

School of Environment and Spatial Informatics, China University of Mining and Technology, Xuzhou 221116, China
 
 
 
KEYWORDS
TOPICS
ABSTRACT
Hydroxyapatite (HAP) and its modified derivatives represent a feasible approach for remediating lead-contaminated soils, while concerns remain regarding their long-term stability. This study conducted a lab-scale experiment to investigate the synergistic remediation of lead-contaminated soil by HAP and KCl, aiming to efficiently immobilize lead and achieve long-term stabilization. The optimum P:Cl:Pb ratio and the remediation mechanisms were first investigated using the toxicity characteristic leaching procedure, the sequential extraction procedure, and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy. The 50- year stability was then assessed by conducting simulated exposure to different types of rainfall (SO42- :NO3- = 1:1, 2:1, and 4:1; pH = 4.5, 5.6, and 6.5). The results showed that after 14 days of treatment, the optimum mixture of HAP and KCl (P:Cl:Pb = 8:2:1, 3.2 wt% HAP) completely immobilized Pb in soil (4985 mg kg-1 Pb), generating 49% stable residual Pb. The presence of KCl enhanced the Pb immobilization through the formation of Pb5(PO4)3Cl and Pb10(PO4)6(OH)2. Following an additional 50- year simulated rainfall period, the residual Pb fraction further increased to 90%, while the leached Pb concentration remained below the regulatory threshold of 5 mg L-1 (GB 5058.3-2007). These findings indicate successful long-term Pb immobilization for at least 50 years, especially under rainfall conditions.
CONFLICT OF INTEREST
The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.
REFERENCES (78)
1.
KHAN I., IQBAL M., SHAFIQ F. Phytomanagement of lead-contaminated soils: critical review of new trends and future prospects. International Journal of Environmental Science and Technology, 16 (10), 6473, 2019.
 
2.
ALASMARY Z. Lead (Pb) Contamination in Soil and Plants at Military Shooting Ranges and Its Mitigation Strategies: A Comprehensive Review. Processes, 13 (2), 345, 2025.
 
3.
AHMED T., NOMAN M., IJAZ M., ALI S., RIZWAN M., IJAZ U., HAMEED A., AHMAD U., WANG Y., SUN G., LI B. Current trends and future prospective in nanoremediation of heavy metals contaminated soils: A way forward towards sustainable agriculture. Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety, 227, 112888, 2021.
 
4.
WYSZKOWSKA J., BOROS-LAJSZNER E., KUCHARSKI J. The Impact of Soil Contamination with Lead on the Biomass of Maize Intended for Energy Purposes, and the Biochemical and Physicochemical Properties of the Soil. Energies, 17 (5), 1156, 2024.
 
5.
WANG F., YAO J., SI Y., CHEN H., RUSSEL M., CHEN K., QIAN Y., ZARAY G., BRAMANTI E. Short-time effect of heavy metals upon microbial community activity. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 173 (1-3), 510, 2010.
 
6.
ASHRAF U., KANU A.S., DENG Q., MO Z., PAN S., TIAN H., TANG X. Lead (Pb) Toxicity; Physio-Biochemical Mechanisms, Grain Yield, Quality, and Pb Distribution Proportions in Scented Rice. Frontiers in Plant Science, 8, 259, 2017.
 
7.
ORO C.E.D., SAORIN PUTON B.M., VENQUIARUTO L.D., DALLAGO R.M., TRES M.V. Effective Microbial Strategies to Remediate Contaminated Agricultural Soils and Conserve Functions. Agronomy, 14 (11), 2637, 2024.
 
8.
RAI P.K., LEE S.S., ZHANG M., TSANG Y.F., KIM K.-H. Heavy metals in food crops: Health risks, fate, mechanisms, and management. Environment International, 125, 365, 2019.
 
9.
AHMED W., MEHMOOD S., MAHMOOD M., ALI S., NÚÑEZ-DELGADO A., LI W. Simultaneous immobilization of lead and arsenic and improved phosphorus availability in contaminated soil using biochar composite modified with hydroxyapatite and oxidation: Findings from a pot experiment. Environmental Research, 235, 116640, 2023.
 
10.
ALABOUDI K.A., AHMED B., BRODIE G. Phytoremediation of Pb and Cd contaminated soils by using sunflower (Helianthus annuus) plant. Annals of Agricultural Sciences, 63 (1), 123, 2018.
 
11.
RHEE YOUNG J., HILLIER S., GADD GEOFFREY M. Lead Transformation to Pyromorphite by Fungi. Current Biology, 22 (3), 237, 2012.
 
12.
SHAO Y., YAN T., WANG K., HUANG S., YUAN W., QIN F.G.F. Soil heavy metal lead pollution and its stabilization remediation technology. Energy Reports, 6, 122, 2020.
 
13.
CHANG J.-H., WANG Y.-L., DONG C.-D., SHEN S.-Y. The particle-size sieving technique to remediate Pband Cu-contaminated agricultural soil. Environmental Geotechnics, 9 (2), 124, 2022.
 
14.
GONG Y., ZHAO D., WANG Q. An overview of fieldscale studies on remediation of soil contaminated with heavy metals and metalloids: Technical progress over the last decade. Water Research, 147, 440, 2018.
 
15.
VENGRIS T., BINKIENĖ R., SVEIKAUSKAITĖ A. Electrokinetic remediation of lead‐, zinc‐ and cadmiumcontaminated soil. Journal of Chemical Technology & Biotechnology, 76 (11), 1165, 2001.
 
16.
HUANG K., WANG X., YUAN W., XIE J., WANG J., LI J. Remediation of lead-contaminated soil by washing with choline chloride-based deep eutectic solvents. Process Safety and Environmental Protection, 160, 650, 2022.
 
17.
EGENDORF S.P., GROFFMAN P., MOORE G., CHENG Z. The limits of lead (Pb) phytoextraction and possibilities of phytostabilization in contaminated soil: a critical review. International Journal of Phytoremediation, 22 (9), 916, 2020.
 
18.
PAN X., CHEN Z., LI L., RAO W., XU Z., GUAN X. Microbial strategy for potential lead remediation: a review study. World Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology, 33 (2), 35, 2017.
 
19.
LI X., PENG W., JIA Y., LU L., FAN W. Bioremediation of lead contaminated soil with Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Chemosphere, 156, 228, 2016.
 
20.
RIGOLETTO M., CALZA P., GAGGERO E., MALANDRINO M., FABBRI D. Bioremediation Methods for the Recovery of Lead-Contaminated Soils: A Review. Applied Sciences, 10 (10), 3528, 2020.
 
21.
MAHAR A., WANG P., ALI A., GUO Z., AWASTHI M.K., LAHORI A.H., WANG Q., SHEN F., LI R., ZHANG Z. Impact of CaO, fly ash, sulfur and Na2S on the (im)mobilization and phytoavailability of Cd, Cu and Pb in contaminated soil. Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety, 134, 116, 2016.
 
22.
LIANG S.-X., XI X.-C., LI Y.-R. Study of the remediation effects of passivation materials on Pb-contaminated soil. Open Chemistry, 18 (1), 911, 2020.
 
23.
SONG P., XU D., YUE J., MA Y., DONG S., FENG J. Recent advances in soil remediation technology for heavy metal contaminated sites: A critical review. Science of The Total Environment, 838, 156417, 2022.
 
24.
CAO Y., CHEN M., ZHANG J., LI Y., FENG L. Immobilization of lead and cadmium in soil by sulfide. Chinese Journal of Environmental Engineering, 8, 782, 2014 [In Chinese].
 
25.
BASTA N.T., MCGOWEN S.L. Evaluation of chemical immobilization treatments for reducing heavy metal transport in a smelter-contaminated soil. Environmental Pollution, 127 (1), 73, 2004.
 
26.
WILSON C., BRIGMON R.L., KNOX A., SEAMAN J., SMITH G. Effects of Microbial and Phosphate Amendments on the Bioavailability of Lead (Pb) in Shooting Range Soil. Bulletin of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology, 76 (3), 392, 2006.
 
27.
EL‐NAGAR D.A., ABDEL‐HALIM K.Y. Remediation of heavy metals in contaminated soil by using nano‐bentonite, nano‐hydroxyapatite, and nano‐composite. Land Degradation & Development, 32 (16), 4562, 2021.
 
28.
LI Z., ZHOU M.-M., LIN W. The Research of Nanoparticle and Microparticle Hydroxyapatite Amendment in Multiple Heavy Metals Contaminated Soil Remediation. Journal of Nanomaterials, 2014 (1), 168418, 2014.
 
29.
YANG Z., FANG Z., ZHENG L., CHENG W., TSANG P.E., FANG J., ZHAO D. Remediation of lead contaminated soil by biochar-supported nano-hydroxyapatite. Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety, 132, 224, 2016.
 
30.
YANG Z., GONG H., HE F., REPO E., YANG W., LIAO Q., ZHAO F. Iron-doped hydroxyapatite for the simultaneous remediation of lead-, cadmium- and arsenic-co-contaminated soil. Environmental Pollution, 312, 119953, 2022.
 
31.
LIU S., LI H., ZHANG L., HU D., LIU Q. Preparation and characterization of implanted Fe catalyst in hydroxyapatite layer for uniformly dispersion carbon nanotube growth. Applied Surface Science, 455, 75, 2018.
 
32.
CHEN H., YUAN X., XIONG T., JIANG L., WANG H., WU Z. Biochar Facilitated Hydroxyapatite/Calcium Silicate Hydrate for Remediation of Heavy Metals Contaminated Soils. Water, Air, & Soil Pollution, 231 (2), 66, 2020.
 
33.
STÖTZEL C., MÜLLER F.A., REINERT F., NIEDERDRAENK F., BARRALET J.E., GBURECK U. Ion adsorption behaviour of hydroxyapatite with different crystallinities. Colloids and Surfaces B: Biointerfaces, 74 (1), 91, 2009.
 
34.
MIN M., SHEN L., HONG G., ZHU M., ZHANG Y., WANG X., CHEN Y., HSIAO B.S. Micro-nano structure poly(ether sulfones)/poly(ethyleneimine) nanofibrous affinity membranes for adsorption of anionic dyes and heavy metal ions in aqueous solution. Chemical Engineering Journal, 197, 88, 2012.
 
35.
WANG Y., LI R., LIU W., CHENG L., JIANG Q., ZHANG Y. Exploratory of immobilization remediation of hydroxyapatite (HAP) on lead-contaminated soils. Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 26 (26), 26674, 2019.
 
36.
SELEIMAN M.F., KHEIR A.M.S. Maize productivity, heavy metals uptake and their availability in contaminated clay and sandy alkaline soils as affected by inorganic and organic amendments. Chemosphere, 204, 514, 2018.
 
37.
WANG J., SHI L., ZHAI L., ZHANG H., WANG S., ZOU J., SHEN Z., LIAN C., CHEN Y. Analysis of the long-term effectiveness of biochar immobilization remediation on heavy metal contaminated soil and the potential environmental factors weakening the remediation effect: A review. Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety, 207, 111261, 2021.
 
38.
HUANG D., DENG R., WAN J., ZENG G., XUE W., WEN X., ZHOU C., HU L., LIU X., XU P., GUO X., REN X. Remediation of lead-contaminated sediment by biochar-supported nano-chlorapatite: Accompanied with the change of available phosphorus and organic matters. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 348, 109, 2018.
 
39.
SCHECKEL K.G., RYAN J.A. Effects of Aging and pH on Dissolution Kinetics and Stability of Chloropyromorphite. Environmental Science & Technology, 36 (10), 2198, 2002.
 
40.
PONTONI D., FREITAS MELO V., BORGO J., STIPP R., JANICE BONFLEUR E. Integrated assessment of the liquid and solid phases of lead-contaminated soils remediated with phosphate. Geoderma, 360, 113993, 2020.
 
41.
MIRETZKY P., FERNANDEZ-CIRELLI A. Phosphates for Pb immobilization in soils: a review. Environmental Chemistry Letters, 6 (3), 121, 2008.
 
42.
LIU J., ZHA F., XU L., YANG C., CHU C., TAN X. Effect of chloride attack on strength and leaching properties of solidified/stabilized heavy metal contaminated soils. Engineering Geology, 246, 28, 2018.
 
43.
WANG L., LI Y., LI H., LIAO X., WEI B., YE B., ZHANG F., YANG L., WANG W., KRAFFT T. Stabilize lead and cadmium in contaminated soils using hydroxyapatite and potassium chloride. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment, 186 (12), 9041, 2014.
 
44.
YAN Y., QI F., ZHAO S., LUO Y., GU S., LI Q., ZHANG L., ZHOU S., BOLAN N. A new low-cost hydroxyapatite for efficient immobilization of lead. Journal of Colloid and Interface Science, 553, 798, 2019.
 
45.
YAN Y., LI Q., YANG J., ZHOU S., WANG L., BOLAN N. Evaluation of hydroxyapatite derived from flue gas desulphurization gypsum on simultaneous immobilization of lead and cadmium in contaminated soil. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 400, 123038, 2020.
 
46.
LIU G., LIAO B., LU T., WANG H., XU L., LI Z., YE C. Insight into immobilization of Pb2+ in aqueous solution and contaminated soil using hydroxyapatite/attapulgite composite. Colloids and Surfaces A: Physicochemical and Engineering Aspects, 603, 125290, 2020.
 
47.
WANG H., JU C., ZHOU M., CHEN J., KAN X., DONG Y., HOU H. Acid rain-dependent detailed leaching characteristics and simultaneous immobilization of Pb, Zn, Cr, and Cd from hazardous lead-zinc tailing. Environmental Pollution, 307, 119529, 2022.
 
48.
XIONG H., FAN H., GAO J., LIU L. Lead speciation evolution and leaching characteristics of lead contaminated soil solidified and stabilized with phosphorus containing substrate. Environmental Engineering, 37, 39, 2019 [In Chinese].
 
49.
BAI X., ZHANG M., ZHANG Y., XU Z., JIANG J., LIU X., HU J., LUO P. Ecotoxicological effects of coal fly ash on Daphnia magna: The effect of particulates and leached hazardous trace elements. Desalination and Water Treatment, 324, 101410, 2025.
 
50.
FRENTIU T., PONTA M., HATEGAN R. Validation of an analytical method based on the high-resolution continuum source flame atomic absorption spectrometry for the fast-sequential determination of several hazardous/priority hazardous metals in soil. Chemistry Central Journal, 7 (1), 43, 2013.
 
51.
GEGENSCHATZ S.A., CHIAPPINI F.A., TEGLIA C.M., MUÑOZ DE LA PEÑA A., GOICOECHEA H.C. Binding the gap between experiments, statistics, and method comparison: A tutorial for computing limits of detection and quantification in univariate calibration for complex samples. Analytica Chimica Acta, 1209, 339342, 2022.
 
52.
BURTON E.D., LAMB D.T., HAMILTON J., MILLER G., JOHNSTON S.G., KARIMIAN N. Remediation of Pb-contaminated soil using modified bauxite refinery residue. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 437, 129339, 2022.
 
53.
SHEN Z., PAN S., HOU D., O'CONNOR D., JIN F., MO L., XU D., ZHANG Z., ALESSI D.S. Temporal effect of MgO reactivity on the stabilization of lead contaminated soil. Environment International, 131, 104990, 2019.
 
54.
QI F., LAMB D., NAIDU R., BOLAN N.S., YAN Y., OK Y.S., RAHMAN M.M., CHOPPALA G. Cadmium solubility and bioavailability in soils amended with acidic and neutral biochar. Science of The Total Environment, 610, 1457, 2018.
 
55.
SHANG C., CHAI Y., PENG L., SHAO J., HUANG H., CHEN A. Remediation of Cr(VI) contaminated soil by chitosan stabilized FeS composite and the changes in microorganism community. Chemosphere, 327, 138517, 2023.
 
56.
LIU X., ZHANG S., ZHANG X., GUO H., LOU Z., ZHANG W., CHEN Z. Cr(VI) immobilization in soil using lignin hydrogel supported nZVI: Immobilization mechanisms and long-term simulation. Chemosphere, 305, 135393, 2022.
 
57.
JIANG J., CHEN H., LI Q., XIA X., MA J., WANG L., LUO P. Reduction and immobilization of Cr(VI)-contaminated soil using FeSO4 combined with (NH4)2HPO4: The remediation efficiency, mechanisms, and long-term stability. Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering, 12 (5), 113368, 2024.
 
58.
SUZUKI T., NAKAMURA A., NIINAE M., NAKATA H., FUJII H., TASAKA Y. Lead immobilization in artificially contaminated kaolinite using magnesium oxide-based materials: Immobilization mechanisms and long-term evaluation. Chemical Engineering Journal, 232, 380, 2013.
 
59.
FAN J., BU C., QI Y., ZHOU W., WANG C., WEI Y., SIDDIQUE K.H.M. Biocrusts significantly affect the bioavailability and ecological risk of heavy metals in gold mine tailings. Plant and Soil, 493 (1-2), 99, 2023.
 
60.
XU H., YANG L., WANG P., LIU Y., PENG M. Kinetic research on the sorption of aqueous lead by synthetic carbonate hydroxyapatite. Journal of Environmental Management, 86 (1), 319, 2008.
 
61.
DOROZHKIN S.V. Dissolution mechanism of calcium apatites in acids: A review of literature. World Journal of Methodology, 2 (1), 1, 2012.
 
62.
SESHADRI B., BOLAN N.S., CHOPPALA G., KUNHIKRISHNAN A., SANDERSON P., WANG H., CURRIE L.D., TSANG D.C.W., OK Y.S., KIM G. Potential value of phosphate compounds in enhancing immobilization and reducing bioavailability of mixed heavy metal contaminants in shooting range soil. Chemosphere, 184, 197, 2017.
 
63.
BAILLIEZ S., NZIHOU A., BÈCHE E., FLAMANT G. Removal of Lead (Pb) by Hydroxyapatite Sorbent. Process Safety and Environmental Protection, 82 (2), 175, 2004.
 
64.
MAVROPOULOS E., ROSSI A.M., COSTA A.M., PEREZ C.A.C., MOREIRA J.C., SALDANHA M. Studies on the Mechanisms of Lead Immobilization by Hydroxyapatite. Environmental Science & Technology, 36 (7), 1625, 2002.
 
65.
QIAN G., CHEN W., LIM T.T., CHUI P. In-situ stabilization of Pb, Zn, Cu, Cd and Ni in the multi-contaminated sediments with ferrihydrite and apatite composite additives. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 170 (2-3), 1093, 2009.
 
66.
KEDE M.L.F.M., PÉREZ D.V., MOREIRA J.C., MARQUES M. Effect of Phosphates on the Bioavailability and Phytotoxicity of Pb and Cd in Contaminated Soil and Phytoextraction by Vetiver Grass. Journal of Environmental Engineering, 143 (3), 05016008, 2017.
 
67.
LIU F., SU Y., MA C., XIE P., ZHAO J., ZHANG H. Remediation of Pb-Contaminated Soil Using a Novel Magnetic Nanomaterial Immobilization Agent. Bulletin of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology, 108 (2), 315, 2022.
 
68.
BOLAN N.S., ADRIANO D.C., NAIDU R. Role of Phosphorus in (Im)mobilization and Bioavailability of Heavy Metals in the Soil-Plant System. In Reviews of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology: Continuation of Residue Reviews, G.W. Ware, L.A. Albert, F. Bro-Rasmussen, D.G. Crosby, P. de Voogt, H. Frehse, O. Hutzinger, F.L. Mayer, D.P. Morgan, D.L. Park, R.S.H. Yang Eds., Springer New York: New York, NY, pp. 1-44, 2003.
 
69.
PINHEIRO J.P., MOTA A.M., BENEDETTI M.F. Lead and Calcium Binding to Fulvic Acids: Salt Effect and Competition. Environmental Science & Technology, 33 (19), 3398, 1999.
 
70.
BRADL H.B. Adsorption of heavy metal ions on soils and soils constituents. Journal of Colloid and Interface Science, 277 (1), 1, 2004.
 
71.
CAO X., MA L.Q., SINGH S.P., ZHOU Q. Phosphate-induced lead immobilization from different lead minerals in soils under varying pH conditions. Environmental Pollution, 152 (1), 184, 2008.
 
72.
WANG Y., DONG X., CUI J., WEI Z., WANG X. Effect of hydroxyapatite particle size on the formation of chloropyromorphite in anglesite-hydroxyapatite suspensions. RSC Advances, 7 (20), 11896, 2017.
 
73.
TIBERG C., SJÖSTEDT C., PERSSON I., GUSTAFSSON J.P. Phosphate effects on copper(II) and lead(II) sorption to ferrihydrite. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 120, 140, 2013.
 
74.
DEBELA F., AROCENA J.M., THRING R.W., WHITCOMBE T. Organic acids inhibit the formation of pyromorphite and Zn-phosphate in phosphorous amended Pb- and Zn-contaminated soil. Journal of Environmental Management, 116, 156, 2013.
 
75.
LI H., LIU Y., TANG S., YU Z., CAI X., XU S., CHEN Y., WANG M., WANG G. Mechanisms for potential Pb immobilization by hydroxyapatite in a soil-rice system. Science of The Total Environment, 783, 147037, 2021.
 
76.
NOVOSEL B., LJUBIČIĆ P. Methodics of precipitation processes on lead sulfate system in aqueous medium. Colloid and Polymer Science, 256 (10), 1009, 1978.
 
77.
ELZAHABI M., YONG R.N. pH influence on sorption characteristics of heavy metal in the vadose zone. Engineering Geology, 60 (1-4), 61, 2001.
 
78.
BADAWY S.H., HELAL M.I.D., CHAUDRI A.M., LAWLOR K., MCGRATH S.P. Soil Solid‐Phase Controls Lead Activity in Soil Solution. Journal of Environmental Quality, 31 (1), 162, 2002.
 
eISSN:2083-5906
ISSN:1230-1485
Journals System - logo
Scroll to top